Steve Liles - Crewe Review

Last updated : 04 April 2004 By Bigrich.....

Two weeks ago we were left in disbelief that we somehow managed to take only one point from the derby with Sheffield United. Similarly yesterday we were left in disbelief that a game of total all out attacking, dominated by the Millers, was left goalless.


With Macca and Swailes both out and Talbot departed, Butler picked up the Captain’s armband. Shaun Barker replaced Chris Swailes in the centre and Paul Warne returned to the right wing in place of the injured Chris Sedgwick. Crewe also welcomed back their captain, David Wright, and Craig Hignett replaced top scorer Steve Jones after the latter’s midweek International duty with Northern Ireland.


Sedgy - Missed Out
With Sedwick missing and the midfield of Morris, Mullin and Warne outbattling Crewe for every ball and streaming forward to support the attack in every move, Monkhouse chose the day to display his new found confidence in taking up an almost free role in the middle of the park. No longer is this talented winger drifting in and out of games but just as Sedgy found in his first season in Division One, sometimes you have to go and look for the ball. Monkhouse did just that and gave Crewe the runaround for most of the afternoon.


The onslaught began early, Shaun Barker striking a right foot shot straight at the keeper from a freekick in the clearest opening of the first 15 minutes before the referee stamped his incompetence onto the game. A typical foraging run by Mullin into the Crewe penalty area ended with the keeper clearly bringing down

Johnny Mullin - Brought Down
Mullin, right in front of the referee and directly in front of the worst linesman I have seen since the Maine Road debacle two season’s earlier. The ball had gone past the keeper and the keeper clearly brought down Mullin, of that there can be no doubt. Therefore there could only be two possible outcomes. Either the referee believing the goalkeeper got a slight touch to the ball in the first instance and therefore a corner, or no touch and therefore a penalty. Of course he therefore gave a goalkick, an absolutely impossible decision and the kind of officiating that frustrates players and fans alike. The Rotherham players surrounded the referee but with no accountability having to be taken by the officials it was clearly all to no avail.


This did however spur Rotherham on even more. A fantastic block by Proctor from an attempted clearance with sublime skills to control and then feed Monkhouse resulted with Monkhouse taking the ball past two defenders despite being held and ran through unchallenged into the area only for the lively Ben Williams, recently signed on loan from Manchester United and looking an excellent prospect for the future, to make a fantastic save from just 7 yards out. Proctor following up the save, somehow failed to scramble the ball over the line and in the melee that followed somehow Crewe managed to keep the ball out when it seemed certain that someone would be able to supply the final touch.

A few minutes later and Monkhouse, now finding space on the right side of midfield, fed a glorious pass down the right flank for Butler to run on to. He cut inside his defender and running across the 18 yard box shot too weakly with his left foot and Williams was able to gather comfortably.


Crewe then responded with a couple of long range shots, firstly Craig Hignett firing over the bar before the impressive Kenny Lunt forced Pollit into his first action from fully 30 yards, the swirling wind clearly helping the force of the shot.

After being outplayed for most of the half, Crewe then nearly took an unexpected lead when Dean Ashton, fresh from his goalscoring exploits with the England U21s against Sweden on Tuesday night, headed down for Justin Cochrane to strike an almost perfect volley past Pollit but thankfully for the Millers it struck the inside of the post and out to safety. Crewe at this point were enjoying the advantage but were failing to create any real chances and by halftime it was Rotherham who should have been clearly ahead.


The second half carried on in very much the same vein. Rotherham probably dominating even more although clearcut chances were fewer. The best chance of the half coming early on when Monkhouse once again ran forwards with the Crewe defence holding off him, clearly respectful of the danger he was posing, before delivering a perfect cross to the far post where Proctor had run in unmarked only to somehow jump under the ball when it seemed a simple knock in would reopen his own personal account.


Proctor and Mullin both had long range free kick attempts and Butler headed just wide following a Scott Minto cross. In the last few minutes Monkhouse struck a ferocious freekick from the left hand side of the penalty area but it was too close to Williams when surely any kind of touch from one of the strikers would have deflected the ball into the net.


There was no doubting which team were the happier with the point at the end of the match and after the recent run of away performances against teams scraping at the wrong end of the table at least Rotherham can hold their heads up high this morning having done everything except put the ball in the back of the net.


A couple of points to note from yesterdays match. In my analysis following the Arsenal match in October I noted how the Arsenal attack defended by using their strikers to chase down and pressurise the opposing defence, thereby making it difficult to bring the ball out of defence with any purpose and cutting the supply off at the earliest opportunity. Butler and Proctor once again worked tirelessly in closing down every time Crewe tried to bring the ball forward, usually resulting in a long hopeful punt up the field or a hurried clearance out of play. This resulted in Rotherham keeping possession and also added to the frustration of the Crewe performance.

I have heard a couple of disgruntled comments about Proctor’s lack of goals on the message board lately but this is surely nonsense when he possesses such ability of the like I have failed to see in any Rotherham striker in years. His first touch is the most assured of all the Rotherham team and his partnership with Butler has clearly flourished even though they have only played together 9 times.


Man Of The Match
Man of the Match has to be Shaun Barker. Considering this guy has been out injured for the past few weeks and is only filling in at Centre Back in Swailes’ absence he won every header and every challenge from one of the most highly rated young strikers in this division. Dean Ashton is a tall, stocky, athletic footballer rightly winning praise for his ability and potential witnessed this week in Sweden where he scored the first goal for the England U21 squad. However, at just one year older, our very own Shaun Barker decisively and powerfully won every header against him and consistently won the battles on the ground, tackling and winning possession as well as linking up well in attack both as a provider from out wide and as a goal threat within the opposing box.


Warney - 100%
A special mention must be made for Paul Warne too. Another player who always gives 100% and takes more than his fair share of stick although most Rotherham fans understand his commitment can never be questioned. Yesterday in typical Warne style he harried the Crewe midfield consistently and tracked back and won so many balls against the run of play turning defence into attack on numerous occasions.


Although it could so easily have been three points yesterday, any away result has to be seen as a point gained. If we can take maximum points from our game in hand on Tuesday then we will be almost over the finishing line. With Nottingham Forest surprisingly taking three points at Bramall Lane yesterday one of the teams with the most difficult run-ins has suddenly given themselves a lifeline while the surprising home defeat by Walsall has left Derby in a very difficult position although they still have a number of winnable matches left the pressure is now on them to actually go out and win those matches.

Watford still face the most difficult run-in of all the teams in trouble but one good or bad result either way can suddenly place a whole new perspective on the table and it is important that Rotherham gain the necessary points sooner rather than later.